roseandheather wrote:Another casting suggestion for Melissa Mailey: the ridiculously talented Marcia Gay Harden. She's all wrong physically (long dark hair, much too gorgeous) but she could play Melissa's personality like nobody's business and her smile is phenomenal.
Many of the casting suggestions are amusing rather than valuable. The closest current analogy to 1632 is Game of Thrones. Almost no one had heard of most of the cast beforehand. The show made them stars.
Sean Bean, the only really known name, was hired knowing that he would be doing only one season. Peter Dinklage was barely known except by movie afficiandos. The other originals were either character actors or newcomers.
Doing a long-term part on a show means giving up a real lot of time and for someone relatively well-known that means a lot of money. Chances are those chosen for uptimers would be Americans and those for downtimers Europeans. But Melissa, after the start, is not present all that much. Same for many characters.
I don't care how close any of the characters comes to looking like people in the book. Rebecca is supposed to be beautiful. I don't really care what color her hair is. I was just in Spain and there were plenty of blondes and red heads. Who really cares that much? I want to see a show and I'd take Peter Dinklage as Mike Stearns if we got it...well, that is a bit too far.