Topic Actions

Topic Search

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 49 guests

Human Treecat Names

Join us in talking discussing all things Honor, including (but not limited to) tactics, favorite characters, and book discussions.
Re: Human Treecat Names
Post by cthia   » Thu Aug 25, 2022 10:42 am

cthia
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 14951
Joined: Thu Jan 23, 2014 1:10 pm

ThinksMarkedly wrote:
cthia wrote:Why can't someone be kidnapped like LT. Meares was kidnapped and infect them with nanites in the same way, but also install a device that digitally records everything seen and heard. Like the device the Klingons secretly installed in Geordi's visor to see the frequency of the shields when he went down to engineering and glanced at the screen.


Tim Meares wasn't kidnapped. All that happened to him was that his cab driver blew a nanite smoke puff on him without him ever realising that it was a problem. That was such an innocuous happenstance that it would never occur to him that he was being compromised, so he'd report to RMN security. Someone who's been kidnapped should never be let back on duty until fully cleared by a panel that includes toxicological and psychological screening.

Star Trek is not very realistic in that sense. I watch it and enjoy it (especially SNW nowadays), but I am really sad that the Pocket Books late-24th century stores were brushed aside for Star Trek: Picard, which is not good sci-fi. The books had their flaws, but they were at least consistently above the majority of Picard and Discovery plotlines.

Back in the HV, I suppose the MAlign could have some other techniques up their sleeves that would allow them to hide the fact that someone was kidnapped in the first place. But those may themselves have flaws: we know that compulsion can be detected by treecats (see Princess Adrienne's short story); any new technique the MAlign has come up with is therefore untested against treecats, so they wouldn't know for sure that detection is impossible.

But granting them that it works, what do they gain about it? Finding the location of Bolthole would be a major coup, but not very actionable. The Sanctuary system is surrounded by thick clouds of gas, so a ship passing through will be detectable, stealth or no stealth. It's also defended against all conventional attacks, so the RF couldn't send marshall a force strong enough to take it out -- not even if they combined with all of Galton and the SLN had prior to their respective surrenders.

This is even assuming they can tell the location. Most people aboard ships going to Bolthole won't know where they're going. They may be able to report how long the trip took and that it involved a wormhole transit, but not where it led unless they had access to navigational charts, which one be lying around.

They wouldn't have to kidnap their own people. You just install the device during the next series of doctor's appts, or dental appts when they are put to sleep. Also, the nanites themselves wouldn't store the knowledge. A chip installed somewhere in the brain would store the wealth of knowledge.

Son, your mother says I have to hang you. Personally I don't think this is a capital offense. But if I don't hang you, she's gonna hang me and frankly, I'm not the one in trouble. —cthia's father. Incident in ? Axiom of Common Sense
Top
Re: Human Treecat Names
Post by tlb   » Thu Aug 25, 2022 11:11 am

tlb
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 3854
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2012 11:34 am

cthia wrote:They wouldn't have to kidnap their own people. You just install the device during the next series of doctor's appts, or dental appts when they are put to sleep. Also, the nanites themselves wouldn't store the knowledge. A chip installed somewhere in the brain would store the wealth of knowledge.

It the person already worked for the Malign, then they could function as the "recording device" and they would be no need for a chip. However then the person would fail to pass the cat's lie detection.

If the person does not work for the Malign, then they would wonder about brain surgery occurring at a dentist (or a routine doctor's visit). Note that the chip might have to store a year's worth of audio-visual data, depending on the length of a normal stay at Bolthole.

PS: an attack by forces of the Renaissance Factor on Bolthole would be just as an important piece of information as the location of Bolthole; but it would be information detrimental to the plans of the Malign.
Top
Re: Human Treecat Names
Post by ThinksMarkedly   » Thu Aug 25, 2022 11:21 am

ThinksMarkedly
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4103
Joined: Sat Aug 17, 2019 11:39 am

tlb wrote:Finding the location of bolthole would leave it open to a Oyster Bay type of attack. A low speed ballistic entry would not affect the dust clouds enough to be detectable and the orbital factories and shipyards would be easy to find.


I doubt it. It would need to be slower than Voyager 1 to not disturb the dust clouds. That means it would take a year or two to cross them. The next problem is that the stealth ships need to emit excess heat in some direction, but all directions reflect back in a scattered fashion due to those clouds.
Top
Re: Human Treecat Names
Post by tlb   » Thu Aug 25, 2022 11:33 am

tlb
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 3854
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2012 11:34 am

tlb wrote:Finding the location of bolthole would leave it open to a Oyster Bay type of attack. A low speed ballistic entry would not affect the dust clouds enough to be detectable and the orbital factories and shipyards would be easy to find.

ThinksMarkedly wrote:I doubt it. It would need to be slower than Voyager 1 to not disturb the dust clouds. That means it would take a year or two to cross them. The next problem is that the stealth ships need to emit excess heat in some direction, but all directions reflect back in a scattered fashion due to those clouds.

I do not dispute that a speed low enough to avoid detection might take over a year.

However such an approach would only need enough power for the instruments needed to detect when the missile arrived; which should not generate enough heat to be detectable.
Top
Re: Human Treecat Names
Post by Somtaaw   » Thu Aug 25, 2022 11:08 pm

Somtaaw
Rear Admiral

Posts: 1184
Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2014 11:36 am
Location: Canada

tlb wrote:If the person does not work for the Malign, then they would wonder about brain surgery occurring at a dentist (or a routine doctor's visit). Note that the chip might have to store a year's worth of audio-visual data, depending on the length of a normal stay at Bolthole.



In excess of 4 T-years by my reckoning. Tim Meares only got sprayed because as the Flag Lieutenant of Honor, who HAD to have frequent ground-side meetings was particularly exposed. If she'd been anything other than Eighth Fleet Flag at the time and needing the absolute latest intelligence on Haven as early as possible, it's doubtful he was at much risk.

Admiral Kuzak, when she had Third Fleet "defending" San Martin when Manticore liberated in somewhere around 1907 was only a single Junction transit away from Manticore but her fleet stayed on station until post-Buttercup approximately 1915.

Captain Young and the rest of Warlock's crew, on the Admiralty shitlist over his personal fumbling at Basilisk, suffered almost 4 years of dregs duty with little to no chance for shore leave.

The ships protecting Hancock also didn't get much beyond getting to 'unwind' at whatever bars were on Hancock station, besides the shipyard segment.


Home Fleets are about the only ones who regularly got to go on shore leave, purely because it seems to be a rarity home systems are actually attacked, and you need some way to make such duties more appealing. Being able to hit the local bars once every 2-3 weeks, instead of once every 2-3 T-years is a fairly good incentive no?


Since the wormhole connecting to Bolthole isn't directly connected to anything major, it's a safe bet that any ships tasked with directly protecting Bolthole are "there for duration". Since it's also a major shipyard, you can't even 'pull a Pavel Young' and leave post for 'urgent repairs'. You get to leave Bolthole once every 3-4 T-years as part of regular leave, but otherwise you're stuck there.
Top
Re: Human Treecat Names
Post by Jonathan_S   » Fri Aug 26, 2022 12:13 am

Jonathan_S
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 8269
Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2011 2:01 pm
Location: Virginia, USA

Somtaaw wrote:Home Fleets are about the only ones who regularly got to go on shore leave, purely because it seems to be a rarity home systems are actually attacked, and you need some way to make such duties more appealing. Being able to hit the local bars once every 2-3 weeks, instead of once every 2-3 T-years is a fairly good incentive no?


Since the wormhole connecting to Bolthole isn't directly connected to anything major, it's a safe bet that any ships tasked with directly protecting Bolthole are "there for duration". Since it's also a major shipyard, you can't even 'pull a Pavel Young' and leave post for 'urgent repairs'. You get to leave Bolthole once every 3-4 T-years as part of regular leave, but otherwise you're stuck there.

Even other fleets are usually anchored in an inhabited system (or in Manticore's case at terminus of the Junction) where shore leave can be granted. (And when they aren't I'm sure the navies realize that some kind of off-ship R&R facilities are needed. (Look at the effort the USN went to create them in the Pacific during WWII)

Sure, during OBS-era there probably wasn't any shore leave back to Manticore - and any shore leave of Basilisk would be pretty limited in what you could do. But with 8th fleet back for weeks at a time between raids I'd be surprised if there wasn't some shore leave to San Martin -- or even a rotation of crew getting weekend passes that would allow them to get briefly back to Manticore, Sphinx, or Gryphon. (Or just spend more time drinking and partying on San Martin :D)

And at Bolthole you've got the whole planet of Sanctuary where you could grant the defending fleet's sailors shore leave. That's an old and pretty populous colony -- it's going to have plenty of places where sailors can blow off steam. So it's not like they'd be stuck on their ship, or a naval yard, for the entire duration of their tour.
Top
Re: Human Treecat Names
Post by Somtaaw   » Fri Aug 26, 2022 1:31 am

Somtaaw
Rear Admiral

Posts: 1184
Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2014 11:36 am
Location: Canada

Jonathan_S wrote:
Somtaaw wrote:Home Fleets are about the only ones who regularly got to go on shore leave, purely because it seems to be a rarity home systems are actually attacked, and you need some way to make such duties more appealing. Being able to hit the local bars once every 2-3 weeks, instead of once every 2-3 T-years is a fairly good incentive no?


Since the wormhole connecting to Bolthole isn't directly connected to anything major, it's a safe bet that any ships tasked with directly protecting Bolthole are "there for duration". Since it's also a major shipyard, you can't even 'pull a Pavel Young' and leave post for 'urgent repairs'. You get to leave Bolthole once every 3-4 T-years as part of regular leave, but otherwise you're stuck there.

Even other fleets are usually anchored in an inhabited system (or in Manticore's case at terminus of the Junction) where shore leave can be granted. (And when they aren't I'm sure the navies realize that some kind of off-ship R&R facilities are needed. (Look at the effort the USN went to create them in the Pacific during WWII)

Sure, during OBS-era there probably wasn't any shore leave back to Manticore - and any shore leave of Basilisk would be pretty limited in what you could do. But with 8th fleet back for weeks at a time between raids I'd be surprised if there wasn't some shore leave to San Martin -- or even a rotation of crew getting weekend passes that would allow them to get briefly back to Manticore, Sphinx, or Gryphon. (Or just spend more time drinking and partying on San Martin :D)

And at Bolthole you've got the whole planet of Sanctuary where you could grant the defending fleet's sailors shore leave. That's an old and pretty populous colony -- it's going to have plenty of places where sailors can blow off steam. So it's not like they'd be stuck on their ship, or a naval yard, for the entire duration of their tour.


Different definitions of shore leave I guess. A few hours, or even a full weekend off to go hit the bars is libery but not truly shore leave, by my definitions.

Shore leave is having a few weeks, or even a full month to do whatever you wish, whenever you wish, however you wish, and zero need to check-in until the end.

And, judging by people like Randy Steilman's musing in HAE, it appears that those are the terms Himself uses to distinguish a weekend to go planetside to blow off steam real quick (and a reward for good behaviour), versus shore leave, convalesce leave (Honor gets a lot of these with how much she got shot up), and whatnot. Using the term 'leave' appears to mean your naval vacation is a month or more, while liberty appears to cover the short stuff.
Top
Re: Human Treecat Names
Post by ThinksMarkedly   » Fri Aug 26, 2022 1:32 pm

ThinksMarkedly
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4103
Joined: Sat Aug 17, 2019 11:39 am

Jonathan_S wrote:And at Bolthole you've got the whole planet of Sanctuary where you could grant the defending fleet's sailors shore leave. That's an old and pretty populous colony -- it's going to have plenty of places where sailors can blow off steam. So it's not like they'd be stuck on their ship, or a naval yard, for the entire duration of their tour.


Even if the fleet is continuously at deployment somewhere remote, it doesn't mean all ships in it are continuously there. Some ships can be replaced with others, which are sent back for maintenance and refit, whereupon the crew can be granted liberty or shore leave. We have multiple instances of admirals discussing the fact that they needed to account for ships in transit in their plans. It's also one of the death knells for the frigate.

Similarly, an entire crew's complement need not be 100% dedicated to the ship while the ship is at station. Unless the ship is on alert condition, it's possible that some crew members are rotated in and out, due to promotions and reassignments, but also due to their leave time accruing. Some of those may get shipped all the way back to a home port where they can get a full leave.
Top
Re: Human Treecat Names
Post by Theemile   » Fri Aug 26, 2022 3:41 pm

Theemile
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 5060
Joined: Sat Feb 27, 2010 5:50 pm
Location: All over the Place - Now Serving Dublin, OH

ThinksMarkedly wrote:
Jonathan_S wrote:And at Bolthole you've got the whole planet of Sanctuary where you could grant the defending fleet's sailors shore leave. That's an old and pretty populous colony -- it's going to have plenty of places where sailors can blow off steam. So it's not like they'd be stuck on their ship, or a naval yard, for the entire duration of their tour.


Even if the fleet is continuously at deployment somewhere remote, it doesn't mean all ships in it are continuously there. Some ships can be replaced with others, which are sent back for maintenance and refit, whereupon the crew can be granted liberty or shore leave. We have multiple instances of admirals discussing the fact that they needed to account for ships in transit in their plans. It's also one of the death knells for the frigate.

Similarly, an entire crew's complement need not be 100% dedicated to the ship while the ship is at station. Unless the ship is on alert condition, it's possible that some crew members are rotated in and out, due to promotions and reassignments, but also due to their leave time accruing. Some of those may get shipped all the way back to a home port where they can get a full leave.


While we've never seen the makeup of fleet trains, there is no reason there isn't an R&R ship as part of the makeup - a rented Cruise ship with entertainment venues to allow ships to rotate portions of their crew to a off duty play space where they can mingle with other ship's crews in a controlled environment. I doubt they would be pulling then behind the front lines, but Grendlesbane or Hancock might see something of the type.

Heck, I can see a Consortium using an older ship (especially if they have been sidelined because of the war) and sending it to the fleetbase just to "provide" the service".
******
RFC said "refitting a Beowulfan SD to Manticoran standards would be just as difficult as refitting a standard SLN SD to those standards. In other words, it would be cheaper and faster to build new ships."
Top
Re: Human Treecat Names
Post by cthia   » Tue Aug 30, 2022 1:31 am

cthia
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 14951
Joined: Thu Jan 23, 2014 1:10 pm

ThinksMarkedly wrote:
tlb wrote:Finding the location of bolthole would leave it open to a Oyster Bay type of attack. A low speed ballistic entry would not affect the dust clouds enough to be detectable and the orbital factories and shipyards would be easy to find.


I doubt it. It would need to be slower than Voyager 1 to not disturb the dust clouds. That means it would take a year or two to cross them. The next problem is that the stealth ships need to emit excess heat in some direction, but all directions reflect back in a scattered fashion due to those clouds.

Shouldn't those same dust clouds impede Haven's own sensors? Like when Kirk took a wounded Enterprise into the Mutara Nebula (dust clouds) to even the odds against Khan.

Son, your mother says I have to hang you. Personally I don't think this is a capital offense. But if I don't hang you, she's gonna hang me and frankly, I'm not the one in trouble. —cthia's father. Incident in ? Axiom of Common Sense
Top

Return to Honorverse