Topic Actions

Topic Search

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 42 guests

Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?

Join us in talking discussing all things Honor, including (but not limited to) tactics, favorite characters, and book discussions.
Re: Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?
Post by Lord Skimper   » Thu Aug 07, 2014 8:58 pm

Lord Skimper
Vice Admiral

Posts: 1736
Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 12:49 am
Location: Calgary, Nova, Gryphon.

Direwolf18 wrote:According to RFC it doesnt mind them at all! Why is this so hard when RFC is so clear. Unless you wan't to argue with RFC about what he does in his own universe. (Which I can name 1-2 people on these forums who do)

IF they are breaking the laws of war and acting like rapist and murders, then yes, they are going to find themselves taking a walk outside an airlock without a skinsuit. If they act as soldiers for hire, following such trifling things as the rules of war, then they will be treated as such.


I don't argue with him so much as discuss alternatives...

One might think of Private contractors in the last set of wars. Anything from Infamous Black Water or whatever they are called now, to the truck drivers who kept the supplies rolling.
________________________________________
Just don't ask what is in the protein bars.
Top
Re: Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?
Post by runsforcelery   » Thu Aug 07, 2014 9:43 pm

runsforcelery
First Space Lord

Posts: 2425
Joined: Sun Aug 09, 2009 11:39 am
Location: South Carolina

Roguevictory wrote:
Mitchell, Esq. wrote:Why about Zilwicki's 'private security company'?

He's a merc outfit, without question... one that is operating on Manticore without trouble.

Mercenaries are not always bad to have around. Retired service people may have skills that are needed by the government for special jobs which can't be handled by uniformed services or other agencies in government.

Perhaps one want to support a government which is friendly... but you don't want to do so officially.

No problem. Find retired or separated people with the skills you need... and they go on 'vacation' to parts unknown for a year or two.


SWM wrote:I thought RFC made it clear that Manticore doesn't have a problem with mercenaries as such. It doesn't use them itself, and avoids situations where it would have to work with them, but does not prevent private companies from hiring mercenaries or security services, and does not prevent citizens from being hired as mercenaries or security services.


It doesn't seem to mind them if they are helping it though, see Honor's middy cruise captain who ran an armed cargo company that supplied intel to ONI. I wonder what happened to him after War of Honor?


How does Bachfish's armed ship constitute a "mercenary" force? His ships were armed solely for self-protection, which has been --- and still is --- a recognized right for vessels plying the high seas. Now, most present day ports are likely to throw a hissy fit and stiffly regulate (or more probablky probably exclude) any armed merchantmen entering their waters, but up until the very late 19th century, it was not at all uncommon for private vessels operating in uncertain waters to be armed. The current situation in which ships aren't even sufficiently well-armed to resist teenagers in speedboats off Somalia is totally out of step with the vast majority of maritime history. This may or may not be a good thing in our own experience, but if Bachfish's armament makes him a mercenary, then Klaus Hauptman is also a mercenary for having armed his passenger liners for self-defense in Silesia.

The definition some people are using for what constitutes a "mercenary force" is way, way, way too broad, in my opinion, in historical terms. And it is certainly enormously broader than anyone in the Honorverse would use.


"Oh, bother!" said Pooh, as Piglet came back from the dead.
Top
Re: Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?
Post by Roguevictory   » Thu Aug 07, 2014 11:09 pm

Roguevictory
Captain of the List

Posts: 419
Joined: Tue May 13, 2014 8:15 pm
Location: Guthrie, Oklahoma, USA

runsforcelery wrote:


How does Bachfish's armed ship constitute a "mercenary" force? His ships were armed solely for self-protection, which has been --- and still is --- a recognized right for vessels plying the high seas. Now, most present day ports are likely to throw a hissy fit and stiffly regulate (or more probablky probably exclude) any armed merchantmen entering their waters, but up until the very late 19th century, it was not at all uncommon for private vessels operating in uncertain waters to be armed. The current situation in which ships aren't even sufficiently well-armed to resist teenagers in speedboats off Somalia is totally out of step with the vast majority of maritime history. This may or may not be a good thing in our own experience, but if Bachfish's armament makes him a mercenary, then Klaus Hauptman is also a mercenary for having armed his passenger liners for self-defense in Silesia.

The definition some people are using for what constitutes a "mercenary force" is way, way, way too broad, in my opinion, in historical terms. And it is certainly enormously broader than anyone in the Honorverse would use.


True though I thought he had to have an auxiliary warrant from the Silesian armed forces to make arming his ships legal. I thought that the auxiliary warrant would make make him and his ships part of a Silesian naval reserve though I guess that really wouldn't make him a mercenary unless he was paid for his services, or any pirates or privateers that his ships captured or destroyed. Sorry for the mixup.
Top
Re: Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?
Post by Jonathan_S   » Fri Aug 08, 2014 3:55 pm

Jonathan_S
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 8269
Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2011 2:01 pm
Location: Virginia, USA

Roguevictory wrote:
True though I thought he had to have an auxiliary warrant from the Silesian armed forces to make arming his ships legal. I thought that the auxiliary warrant would make make him and his ships part of a Silesian naval reserve though I guess that really wouldn't make him a mercenary unless he was paid for his services, or any pirates or privateers that his ships captured or destroyed. Sorry for the mixup.

The Silesian Navy might be corrupt enough not to care, but I suspect most navies would be pretty ticked if they found out one of their armed auxiliaries were off playing mercenary.
Top
Re: Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?
Post by n7axw   » Fri Aug 08, 2014 4:17 pm

n7axw
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 5997
Joined: Wed Jan 22, 2014 8:54 pm
Location: Viborg, SD

Jonathan_S wrote:
Roguevictory wrote:
True though I thought he had to have an auxiliary warrant from the Silesian armed forces to make arming his ships legal. I thought that the auxiliary warrant would make make him and his ships part of a Silesian naval reserve though I guess that really wouldn't make him a mercenary unless he was paid for his services, or any pirates or privateers that his ships captured or destroyed. Sorry for the mixup.

The Silesian Navy might be corrupt enough not to care, but I suspect most navies would be pretty ticked if they found out one of their armed auxiliaries were off playing mercenary.


Bachfish had connections as an old Silesian hand and the impression I got was that he was able to put some money in the proper hands to get the warrant giving him permission to arm his ships. Pat Givens was in the mix there too sinse Bachfish was an intel sourse for ONI. I'm not quite sure how she fit in.

Don
When any group seeks political power in God's name, both religion and politics are instantly corrupted.
Top
Re: Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?
Post by Dafmeister   » Sat Aug 09, 2014 6:19 am

Dafmeister
Commodore

Posts: 754
Joined: Fri Oct 18, 2013 4:58 am

n7axw wrote:
Bachfish had connections as an old Silesian hand and the impression I got was that he was able to put some money in the proper hands to get the warrant giving him permission to arm his ships. Pat Givens was in the mix there too sinse Bachfish was an intel sourse for ONI. I'm not quite sure how she fit in.

Don


He was a merchant captain who still held a commision in the RMN Reserve. A lot of them file reports with ONI as part of their reservist duties.
Top
Re: Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?
Post by KNick   » Sat Aug 09, 2014 8:16 am

KNick
Admiral

Posts: 2142
Joined: Mon Sep 10, 2012 1:38 am
Location: Billings, MT, USA

n7axw wrote:Bachfish had connections as an old Silesian hand and the impression I got was that he was able to put some money in the proper hands to get the warrant giving him permission to arm his ships. Pat Givens was in the mix there too sinse Bachfish was an intel sourse for ONI. I'm not quite sure how she fit in.

Don


I was under the impression that at some point in the process, she was the one greasing the palms of the necessary people. Either that or threatening to break a few heads. Which ever worked.
_


Try to take a fisherman's fish and you will be tomorrows bait!!!
Top
Re: Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?
Post by n7axw   » Sat Aug 09, 2014 6:31 pm

n7axw
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 5997
Joined: Wed Jan 22, 2014 8:54 pm
Location: Viborg, SD

KNick wrote:
n7axw wrote:Bachfish had connections as an old Silesian hand and the impression I got was that he was able to put some money in the proper hands to get the warrant giving him permission to arm his ships. Pat Givens was in the mix there too sinse Bachfish was an intel sourse for ONI. I'm not quite sure how she fit in.

Don


I was under the impression that at some point in the process, she was the one greasing the palms of the necessary people. Either that or threatening to break a few heads. Which ever worked.


The reference is in War of Honor when Bachfish shows up in Marsh the first time. I'd have to dig the book out and am a bit too lazy.

Don
When any group seeks political power in God's name, both religion and politics are instantly corrupted.
Top
Re: Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?
Post by munroburton   » Sat Aug 09, 2014 6:50 pm

munroburton
Admiral

Posts: 2368
Joined: Sat Jun 15, 2013 10:16 am
Location: Scotland

KNick wrote:
n7axw wrote:Bachfish had connections as an old Silesian hand and the impression I got was that he was able to put some money in the proper hands to get the warrant giving him permission to arm his ships. Pat Givens was in the mix there too sinse Bachfish was an intel sourse for ONI. I'm not quite sure how she fit in.

Don


I was under the impression that at some point in the process, she was the one greasing the palms of the necessary people. Either that or threatening to break a few heads. Which ever worked.


Givens is a little bit subtler than breaking heads, surely. :P Her 'threats' would be more like a dossier of the approving authority's unlawful dealings attached to the application form for Bachfisch's warrant, marked for forwarding to the Silesian media in case the target needs a little more convincing.

ONI(and SIS) should have had permanent interests in Silesia, given how long it's been problematic(Edward Saganami died there in 1672pd). Obviously, that depends a lot on what the successive SKM governments let them do, but still. I wouldn't be too surprised to find a variant of the North Hollow Files, documenting much of the corruption in Silesia.
Top
Re: Mercenaries in the Honorverse:Manticore's hypocrisy?
Post by Jonathan_S   » Sat Aug 09, 2014 8:01 pm

Jonathan_S
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 8269
Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2011 2:01 pm
Location: Virginia, USA

n7axw wrote:
Jonathan_S wrote:The Silesian Navy might be corrupt enough not to care, but I suspect most navies would be pretty ticked if they found out one of their armed auxiliaries were off playing mercenary.


Bachfish had connections as an old Silesian hand and the impression I got was that he was able to put some money in the proper hands to get the warrant giving him permission to arm his ships. Pat Givens was in the mix there too sinse Bachfish was an intel sourse for ONI. I'm not quite sure how she fit in.

Don
Yes, I knew why he was allowed to be armed. But my (unstated) thought was that he was using those arms for self-defense. And that most Navies should be happy to let their armed auxiliaries do that (as long as they're not hunting for chances to need to provide self-defense), but most Navies would not be happy with a ship nominally under their banner accepting outside money for military service.

(And then I went off on a tangent about how the Silesian Navy might have been corrupt enough for someone to accept bribes to look the other way if another naval auxiliary of their actually went full mercenary. I wasn't saying the Bachfisch's ships were acting as mercenaries; they aren't)
Top

Return to Honorverse