Exactly. Manticore will always capture pirates and take them to the appropriate local authorities. In Manticore, that is easy, because Manticore will deal harshly with pirates. However, in Silesia, the proper procedure is to hand pirates over to local Silesian authorities, which can have mixed results. The procedure that Honor and the rest of the RMN follow is to hand pirates over once to the local authorities (maintaining the fiction of Silesian control) and enter the pirates into the database, including the government they were handed over to. If another Manticoran ship captures them again, they are summarily executed and it is known to not hand pirates over to that local government. The chance is for the local Silesian government, not for the pirates.
SWM wrote:Cthia, I think the problem is a
misunderstanding of Manticore's zero tolerance policy. It does NOT mean automatic and immediate execution. Zero tolerance means that every pirate is sent to appropriate authorities for trial; they are never simply released. If convicted of piracy, the usual sentence in Manticore is death. But even in Manticore, a lesser sentence can be given in some circumances. In fact, it is possible that a pirate might be acquitted, or convicted of a lesser sentence in some circumstances. Manticoran naval commanders have the authority (but not the obligation) to try pirates in the field, sentence, and execute punishment. But most pirates are simply sent on to a planetary authority for trial.
Honor did not release the pirates. She very correctly handed them over to the local police, along with the evidence. That is not the same as giving the pirates a second chance--the pirates were supposed to go on trial for their crimes. The local government argued (with considerable validity) that they were the appropriate authorities to try local pirates. In turning them over to the police, Honor was fully complying with Manticore's zero tolerance policy toward pirates. She had the option of summary trial and execution, but political considerations weighed in favor of giving the local government a chance to demonstrate their system of justice. That is not really the same as giving the pirates a second chance. Honor was following the zero tolerance policy by turning the pirates over to appropriate authorities for trial.